![[Coins_Value_Logo_new]](https://www.coins-value.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/cropped-Coins_Value_Logo_new-removebg-preview.png){kind=link}
1928 Peace Dollar Value Guide (Key Date Worth $215-$129,000)
Complete 1928 Peace Dollar value guide. The 1928-P is the series key date worth $215+ in all grades. 1928-S is a condition rarity worth $42-$88,000. Prices, VAMs, errors, grading.
The 1928 Peace Dollar is worth $42 to $129,250, with dramatic value differences between the two mints.
- 1928-P (Philadelphia): $215$550 circulated, $1,100$5,500 uncirculated, $21,000$129,000+ top grades
- 1928-S (San Francisco): $42$200 circulated, $235$650 lower uncirculated, $18,500$88,000+ gem grades
- Key insight: The 1928-P is the series key date (360,649 mintage), while the 1928-S is a classic condition rarity with notoriously weak strikes making MS-65+ examples exponentially rare.
What's Your 1928 Dollar Worth?
Select your coin's mint mark and condition to get a value estimate.
Focus on choosing the right sales channel to maximize your return.
Expected: ()
1928 Peace Dollar: Overview
The 1928 Peace Dollar was struck only in Philadelphia and San Francisco
The 1928 Peace Dollar represents the final year of the initial production run of this iconic silver dollar series. Struck at two facilitiesthe Philadelphia Mint (360,649 pieces) and San Francisco Mint (1,632,000 pieces)this year produced one of American numismatics' most dramatic contrasts in collectibility. The 1928-P is the undisputed key date of the entire 24-coin Peace Dollar series, commanding premiums in all grades from heavily worn to gem uncirculated. Conversely, the 1928-S is a textbook condition rarity: common in circulated grades but exponentially scarce in high mint state due to notoriously weak strikes.
Production ended abruptly in 1928 as the U.S. Mint exhausted the silver bullion purchased under the 1918 Pittman Act. The 1928 mintage represented the "leftover" amount required to fulfill this replacement quota, explaining the record-low Philadelphia production. This guide covers identification, comprehensive pricing across all grades, VAM varieties, mint errors, authentication strategies for this heavily counterfeited issue, and preservation best practices.
How to Identify Your 1928 Peace Dollar
Mint mark location: reverse, below ONE, above eagle's tail feathers
The Peace Dollar series, designed by Anthony de Francisci, features a distinctive design that remained consistent throughout the 1920s. The obverse displays Liberty in left-facing profile wearing a radiate (spiked) crown or tiara, symbolizing enlightenment. The word "LIBERTY" appears above, with "IN GOD WE TRVST" along the left border and the date "1928" below. The reverse depicts a bald eagle at rest on a rocky mountain crag, clutching an olive branch in its talons. The word "PEACE" is prominently inscribed below the eagle, with "UNITED STATES OF AMERICA" around the top border and "ONE DOLLAR" at the bottom.
The mint mark location is found on the reverse, below the word "ONE" and just above the eagle's tail feathers. The 1928 Peace Dollar was struck at two facilities:
- 1928 (Philadelphia): No mint mark. The area below "ONE" is blank.
- 1928-S (San Francisco): A small "S" mint mark appears in this location.
The 1928 issue was produced only as business strikes intended for circulation. Zero proof coins were struck in 1928, making any coin advertised as a "1928 Proof" either misidentified or fraudulent. The specifications are standard for the Peace Dollar series: 90% silver and 10% copper composition, 26.73 grams weight, 38.1mm diameter, and a reeded edge. The actual silver weight (ASW) is 0.77344 troy ounces per coin.
A critical identification point concerns strike quality, particularly for the 1928-S. San Francisco-minted examples are notorious for weak, "mushy" strikes, especially on the reverse where the eagle's breast and leg feathers often lack full definition. A sharply struck 1928-S is exceptionally rare and commands enormous premiums. In contrast, Philadelphia strikes tend to be more consistent and sharper, though strike quality should still be evaluated on a coin-by-coin basis.
1928 Peace Dollar Value Guide
The 1928 Peace Dollar market presents a fascinating study in numismatic valuation. The relationship between the two mints creates one of the most dramatic "value flips" in American coinage. The following prices represent current retail values as of November 2025, compiled from PCGS and NGC price guides, major dealer listings, and recent auction results.
1928 (Philadelphia) - The Series Key Date
With a mintage of just 360,649 piecesthe lowest of any Peace Dollarthe 1928-P is valuable in every grade. While it becomes increasingly rare in gem condition, it is paradoxically more available in MS-65 than its higher-mintage San Francisco counterpart due to superior strike quality.
| Grade | Retail Value |
|---|---|
| G-4 | $215$250 |
| VF-20 | $245$280 |
| EF-40 | $290$320 |
| AU-50 | $325$360 |
| MS-60 | $500$550 |
| MS-63 | $1,100$1,400 |
| MS-64 | $2,800$4,000 |
| MS-65 | $3,800$5,500 |
| MS-66 | $21,000$28,000 |
The melt value of approximately $37 (based on $47.85/oz silver as of November 2025) is essentially irrelevant for the 1928-P. Even heavily circulated examples trade at nearly six times the intrinsic bullion value.
1928-S (San Francisco) - The Condition Rarity
Strike quality: 1928-S typically shows weak, mushy reverse details vs sharper 1928-P
The 1928-S presents the opposite value profile. With 1.6 million pieces struck, it is common in circulated grades and trades near bullion value in low grades. However, the legendary weak strikes make gem examples exponentially rarer than the low-mintage 1928-P. The value "flip" occurs at MS-65, where the 1928-S suddenly becomes 4-5 times more valuable than its Philadelphia counterpart.
| Grade | Retail Value |
|---|---|
| G-4 | $45$50 |
| VF-20 | $42$50 |
| EF-40 | $75$85 |
| AU-50 | $125$140 |
| MS-60 | $235$250 |
| MS-63 | $600$650 |
| MS-64 | $900$1,500 |
| MS-65 | $18,500$25,000+ |
| MS-66 | $88,000+ |
The PCGS population report shows only one coin certified at MS-66 for the 1928-S, compared to a small but measurable population at this grade for the 1928-P. The extreme volatility in MS-65 pricing ($7,500 to $51,600 in recent auctions) directly reflects strike qualitylower-priced sales represent "technical" gems with typical weak strikes, while premium sales represent the rare examples with superior sharpness and eye appeal.
Recent Auction Results
The following auction records from 2021-2025 illustrate the market dynamics for both issues. Note how the 1928-S commands progressively higher premiums as grade increases, reflecting the scarcity of well-struck examples.
1928 (Philadelphia) Notable Sales:
- MS-64: $2,640$3,960 (multiple 2023-2024 sales)
- MS-65: $4,320$9,600 (2024-2025 sales; wide range reflects eye appeal variations)
- MS-66: $16,800 (Stack's Bowers, March 2021) to $44,400 (recent sale)
- MS-66+:$129,250 (Legend Rare Coin Auctions, April 2023) auction record for the issue
1928-S (San Francisco) Notable Sales:
- MS-64+: $1,380$3,360 (2023-2025 sales)
- MS-65: $7,500$51,600 (2023-2024; extreme range reflects strike quality)
- MS-65 (premium strike):$51,600 (Heritage Auctions, August 2024)
- MS-65+: $52,800$78,000 (2021-2022 sales)
These auction results confirm that both issues remain highly sought after, with the market willing to pay substantial premiums for superior quality, strike, and eye appeal within each grade level.
Grading the 1928 Peace Dollar
Grade comparison: G-4 (heavy wear), VF-20 (moderate wear), MS-65 (mint luster)
Grading Peace Dollars requires evaluating both wear (for circulated coins) and strike quality (for uncirculated coins). The 1928-S presents unique challenges due to its typically weak strikes, making it critical to distinguish between a weak strike and actual circulation wear.
Circulated Grades (G-4 through AU-58)
The first areas to show wear on a Peace Dollar are Liberty's hair above the ear, her cheek, and the eagle's breast and wing high points on the reverse. In Good-4, the date remains clear but Liberty's hair detail is heavily worn, with only the outline visible. By Very Fine-20, moderate wear is evident but hair strands are distinguishable and the motto remains clear. In Extremely Fine-40, light wear appears on the high points but most design details are sharp. About Uncirculated grades (AU-50 to AU-58) show only slight wear on the highest points, with substantial mint luster remaining in protected areas.
Uncirculated Grades (MS-60 through MS-70)
Mint state coins show no wear from circulation. Grading focuses on contact marks, luster quality, strike sharpness, and eye appeal. MS-60 to MS-62 coins have numerous contact marks and may show bag marks or scuffs, though luster is present. MS-63 examples have moderate marks but better overall eye appeal. MS-64 coins show only minor marks and strong luster. MS-65 pieces have minimal marks visible to the naked eye and exceptional lusterthis is where the 1928-S "wall" occurs, as finding mark-free examples with decent strikes becomes exponentially difficult. MS-66 and higher are virtually mark-free with outstanding eye appeal.
The 1928-S Strike Challenge
The 1928-S is notorious for weak strikes, particularly on the reverse. Even uncirculated examples often show flat, "mushy" detail on the eagle's breast and leg feathers. When evaluating an uncirculated 1928-S, examine the reverse carefully. A coin with full mint luster but weak reverse detail is still technically uncirculated but will grade lower (typically MS-60 to MS-63) than a sharply struck example. The rare 1928-S coins that combine gem surfaces with a sharp strike command the extraordinary premiums documented in the price guide. By contrast, the 1928-P typically exhibits more consistent, sharper strikes, though quality should still be verified coin-by-coin.
Die Varieties (VAMs)
VAM-3 diagnostic: clear doubling visible on reverse motto
The Peace Dollar series uses the Van Allen-Mallis (VAM) attribution system to catalog die varieties. PCGS and NGC primarily recognize the "Top 50" VAMsthe rarest and most discernible varieties that command premiums. The 1928 issue has four notable VAMs worth discussing.
1928 VAM-2 (Doubled Rays/IBER)
This Philadelphia variety shows doubling on the short rays of Liberty's tiara and the letters "IBER" in LIBERTY on the obverse. While not on the official "Top 50" list, it is collected and recognized. The premium is modest but measurable:
| Grade | VAM-2 Value |
|---|---|
| XF-45 | $250$300 |
| AU-55 | $400$450 |
| MS-62 | $750$850 |
1928-S VAM-3 (Doubled Motto) Top 50
The most prominent variety for the 1928-S, VAM-3 exhibits clear doubling on the reverse motto "IN GOD WE TRVST." This Top 50 variety carries significant premiums, particularly in circulated grades where it can be authenticated without the expense of high-grade certification. The PCGS and NGC populations are low (67 and 69 respectively as of late 2024), confirming its scarcity.
| Grade | VAM-3 Value |
|---|---|
| XF-45 | $140$175 |
| AU-55 | $250$300 |
| MS-62 | $350$450 |
A 1928-S VAM-3 in MS-65 would be a monumental rarity, combining a scarce die variety with an already-rare grade for this weakly struck issue. No reliable public pricing exists for such a combination; its value would likely be determined only at major auction.
1928-S VAM-3A (Doubled Motto/Lines) Top 50
This variety shows the same doubled motto as VAM-3 but with additional die polish lines. It carries a slight premium over VAM-3 due to the added diagnostic feature. Values range from $150$200 (XF-45) to $400$500 (MS-62).
1928-S VAM-9 (DDO)
This Doubled Die Obverse variety shows doubling on the date, "LIBERTY," and "IN GOD WE TRVST." Less prominent than VAM-3, it still carries premiums: $75$100 (XF-45), $150$200 (AU-55), $275$350 (MS-62).
Mint Errors
Error coins represent unique, one-of-a-kind minting mistakes. Unlike die varieties (which affect multiple coins from the same dies), each error coin is singular. Values depend heavily on the error's severity, visual appeal, and the coin's base value.
Struck-Through Errors
This error occurs when foreign material (grease, cloth, wire, or debris) lies on the die or planchet during striking, leaving an impression or obscuring design details. For the key-date 1928-P, struck-through errors command substantial premiums. A 1928-P struck-through (obverse) graded PCGS AU Details sold for $450. Despite the "Details" grade (indicating the error classification), the price reflects strong collector interest. A 1928-S struck-through graded NGC MS-63 realized over $900, representing a significant premium over the standard MS-63 value of approximately $650.
Off-Center Strikes
These errors result from improper planchet positioning during striking, causing the dies to strike only a portion of the coin. No specific 1928 examples with documented prices were found in recent auction records, but given the 1928-P's key-date status, a dramatic off-center strike (20-50% off-center) retaining a full date and in high grade (AU or MS) would likely command $1,000 to $3,000+ at auction. The 1928-S, being more common, would command lower premiums unless in exceptional grade.
Blank Planchet
A blank planchet is an unstruck disc (with upset rim from the upsetting mill) that never entered the coining press. These are collectible as "Type 1" mint errors. A Peace Dollar blank planchet (verifiable by weight at 26.73 grams) reportedly sold for over $1,000, reflecting the general scarcity of early 20th century silver dollar blank planchets in the collector market.
Authentication and Counterfeit Detection
Common counterfeit: 1923 altered to 1928 - note incorrect '8' shape
The 1928 Peace Dollar, particularly the key-date Philadelphia issue, ranks among the most heavily counterfeited coins in American numismatics. Three primary counterfeiting methods exist, each requiring specific diagnostic approaches.
Method 1: Altered Date (19231928). Counterfeiters modify a common 1923-P dollar by re-tooling the final "3" into an "8." Detection requires examining the "8" for incorrect proportions, unnatural shape, tooling marks around the digit, or color/luster disturbance in the date area. Genuine 1928 digits have specific shape characteristics that altered dates cannot perfectly replicate.
Removed mint mark detection: look for smoothed area, tooling marks, luster disturbance
Method 2: Removed Mint Mark (1928-S1928). This is the most deceptive and common alteration. A genuine 1928-S has its "S" mint mark carefully removed to create a false "1928-P." Detection strategies include examining the mint mark area for faint tooling marks, a gouged or smoothed appearance, or disturbed metal luster. The most powerful diagnostic is strike quality. The 1928-S is notorious for weak, mushy reverse strikes. If a purported "1928-P" exhibits the characteristic flat, weak reverse strike typical of San Francisco production, it is an immediate red flag for a removed mint mark. Genuine 1928-P strikes tend to be sharper and more complete.
Genuine 1928-P die markers: raised polish lines from B and E in LIBERTY
Method 3: Struck Counterfeits. These fakes are created from entirely fabricated dies. They often exhibit ragged or mushy detail, incorrect weight, wrong surface texture, or non-existent die markers. Some known counterfeits show diagnostic features not found on genuine coins, such as an extra ray of light in Liberty's tiara. Weight is a crucial test: genuine Peace Dollars weigh 26.73 grams.
The best defense against counterfeits is positive identification using genuine die markers. All 360,649 genuine 1928-P coins were struck from only four obverse dies. Key diagnostics include: Die 1 shows a raised die polish line from the middle of the "B" in LIBERTY angling through the tiara. Die 2 has a raised line to the left of the "E" in LIBERTY. Dies 3 and 4 show raised die polish lines extending right from the lower part of the "E" in LIBERTY. Familiarity with these markers is essential for authentication. For any significant purchase, authentication by PCGS or NGC is strongly recommended, particularly for raw (uncertified) coins.
Identifying Cleaned and Problem Coins
Cleaned coin detection: parallel hairlines, unnatural brightness, flat luster
A coin that has been cleaned, polished, "whizzed," or damaged is classified as a "problem coin." PCGS and NGC will not assign numerical grades to such coins; instead, they are encapsulated in "Details" holders (e.g., "AU Details - Cleaned"). The value impact is severea problem coin is worth significantly less than its problem-free counterpart, often dropping to the level of a much lower grade or even approaching melt value for common dates.
Cleaning is identified by microscopic parallel scratches called "hairlines" across the coin's surface, especially visible in the open fields. These result from abrasive wiping or brushing. Polishing creates an unnaturally bright, burnished sheen. While fields may appear very reflective, the luster looks "dead" or "flat" and lacks the proper cartwheel effect of original mint luster. Whizzing involves using a high-speed wire brush to simulate luster, giving the surface a "fuzzy" appearance and often distorting fine lettering and details. Dark, gunky residue in crevices (inside letters, around the date) represents material the cleaning failed to remove.
Natural silver toningranging from light gold to deep charcoalis desirable and can enhance value if attractive. However, artificial toning applied to mask cleaning or defects is detectable through unnatural color patterns, color concentrated in low areas while high points remain bright, or rainbow toning that appears painted-on rather than naturally developed. When in doubt about a coin's originality, third-party certification by PCGS or NGC provides peace of mind and market liquidity.
Preservation and Handling
Proper handling and storage are essential to preserve the value and surface quality of 1928 Peace Dollars. Never hold a collectible coin by its obverse or reverse faces. Always handle coins by their edges to avoid leaving fingerprints, which contain oils and acids that can cause permanent damage over time. When examining a coin, hold it over a soft surface to prevent damage if dropped.
Storage must use inert, archival-quality materials. Do not use soft, flexible PVC-based flips, as these leach harmful plasticizers that cause green "PVC damage"a corrosive residue that can permanently destroy a coin's surface. Instead, use hard plastic capsules (such as those employed by PCGS and NGC), inert Mylar flips, or archival-quality coin albums with non-PVC pages. Store coins in a cool, dry environment with low humidity to prevent spotting, corrosion, or toning acceleration. Avoid attics, basements, or areas with temperature fluctuations.
The cardinal rule of coin preservation: Never clean your coins. Cleaning destroys the original surface and drastically reduces numismatic value. Even "gentle" cleaning with commercial solutions creates microscopic damage visible under magnification. Collectors and dealers prefer original, untouched surfacesincluding naturally acquired toningover artificially cleaned brightness. If a coin requires conservation due to active corrosion or PVC contamination, consult a professional conservation service; never attempt home remedies.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much is my 1928 Peace Dollar worth?Value depends critically on which mint struck your coin and its condition. A 1928 (Philadelphia) with no mint mark is the series key date, worth $215+ even in heavily worn condition, $1,100+ in uncirculated grades, and $20,000+ in gem condition. A 1928-S (San Francisco) with an "S" mint mark is more common, worth $42-$200 circulated, but becomes exponentially rare and valuable ($18,500+) in gem grades due to typically weak strikes. Check the reverse below the word "ONE" for a mint mark to determine which you have.
The mint mark is located on the coin's reverse, below the word "ONE" and just above the eagle's tail feathers. If this area is blank, your coin is a 1928 (Philadelphia). If a small "S" appears, it is a 1928-S (San Francisco). No 1928-D (Denver) Peace Dollars were produced. Use magnification to check carefully, as some counterfeits have removed "S" mint marks to create fake Philadelphia coins.
This counterintuitive situation results from strike quality. The 1928-S was notoriously poorly struck with weak, "mushy" reverse details, particularly on the eagle's breast and leg feathers. Finding a 1928-S that is both mark-free (gem quality) and sharply struck is exponentially difficult. The 1928-P, despite having only 360,649 mintage versus 1.6 million for the S-mint, was more consistently well-struck. At MS-65, the 1928-S is estimated to be nearly three times rarer than the 1928-P, causing the dramatic price flip where the S-mint commands $18,500+ versus $3,800-$5,500 for the P-mint.
For a 1928 (Philadelphia), professional grading by PCGS or NGC is highly recommended regardless of condition, given the key-date status and heavy counterfeiting of this issue. Authentication alone is worth the service fee. For a 1928-S, grading is advisable if the coin appears uncirculated (MS-60 or better) or shows a Top 50 VAM variety. Circulated 1928-S coins in average condition may not justify grading costs unless the variety or error is present. Third-party grading provides authentication, assigns an objective numerical grade, and encapsulates the coin for protection, enhancing both marketability and value.
Genuine 1928-P coins were struck from only four obverse dies, each with identifiable die markers (raised polish lines near the letters in LIBERTY). Counterfeits lack these markers or show incorrect ones. The most common fakes are altered dates (1923 changed to 1928look for tooling around the "8") or removed mint marks (1928-S altered to 1928-Pcheck for smoothing or luster disturbance below "ONE," and note that removed-mintmark fakes often retain the weak strike characteristic of S-mint production). Weight is crucial: genuine coins weigh exactly 26.73 grams. Any significant deviation indicates a fake. When in doubt, submit to PCGS or NGC for authentication.
VAM (Van Allen-Mallis) varieties are die variations caused by differences in die preparation, doubling, repunching, or other minting anomalies. The "Top 50" VAMs are the most collectible. For 1928, the VAM-3 (1928-S, Doubled Motto) is the most significant, showing clear doubling on "IN GOD WE TRVST" and carrying premiums of 2-3x base value in circulated grades. The 1928 VAM-2 (Philadelphia, Doubled Rays) carries modest premiums. VAM collecting is a specialized niche; most collectors focus on base coins by date and mint, but VAMs add another layer of interest and value for dedicated variety enthusiasts.
Use only inert, archival-quality holders such as hard plastic capsules (like those used by PCGS/NGC), rigid plastic holders, or non-PVC Mylar flips. Avoid soft vinyl flips containing PVC, which leach acids causing green corrosive damage. Handle coins only by their edges, never touching the faces. Store in a cool, dry location away from humidity, temperature swings, and direct sunlight. Never attempt to clean the coin, as this destroys original surfaces and value. Natural silver toning is acceptable and often desirable; artificial cleaning is not.
No. Zero proof Peace Dollars were struck in 1928. Any coin described or sold as a "1928 Proof" is either misidentified, fraudulent, or an altered business strike. Some unethical sellers polish high-grade business strikes to create a mirror-like appearance and fraudulently market them as "proofs." Such alteration destroys value and creates a "problem coin." All 1928 Peace Dollars were business strikes intended for circulation. If you encounter a claimed "1928 Proof," approach with extreme skepticism and demand third-party authentication.
Each 1928 Peace Dollar contains 0.77344 troy ounces of fine silver (90% silver composition). Melt value fluctuates with silver spot price. As of November 2025, with silver at approximately $47.85/oz, the melt value is about $37. For the common-grade 1928-S, this creates a semi-numismatic floor (circulated examples trade around $42-$50). For the key-date 1928-P, melt value is essentially irrelevant, as even heavily worn examples command $215+ based solely on numismatic scarcity. Never melt collectible coins for bullion value.
The most significant issue is distinguishing weak strike from wear, particularly on the 1928-S. A coin with full mint luster but flat, mushy reverse details due to weak striking pressure is still technically uncirculated but will grade lower (MS-60 to MS-63) than a sharply struck example. Graders evaluate strike as part of overall quality. For circulated coins, wear appears first on Liberty's hair above the ear, her cheek, and the eagle's breast and wings. Hairlines from cleaning are the most common problem that results in "Details" grades rather than numerical grades. Original, problem-free surfaces with strong eye appeal command premiums within each grade level.
Research Methodology and Disclaimer
This guide synthesizes data from multiple authoritative sources to provide comprehensive, current market information. Primary sources include the PCGS CoinFacts database, NGC Coin Explorer, Heritage Auctions, Stack's Bowers Galleries, and current dealer retail listings from major numismatic firms. Silver spot prices are from JM Bullion as of November 5, 2025. VAM variety information is compiled from PCGS VAM listings and VAMWorld.com. Counterfeit detection information is sourced from NGC counterfeit detection articles and CoinWeek analysis.
Coin values are retail estimates representing typical dealer asking prices for problem-free, original coins in each grade. Actual selling prices may vary based on market conditions, eye appeal, strike quality, and individual buyer/seller circumstances. Auction results reflect actual transactions but can vary significantly based on buyer competition and specific coin attributes. The numismatic market is dynamic; prices fluctuate with precious metal values, collector demand, and economic conditions. This guide is for educational purposes and does not constitute financial, investment, or appraisal advice. For insurance or estate purposes, obtain professional appraisals. Market values presented are current as of November 2025 and may change over time.
A note on images: To help illustrate coin diagnostics and rare varieties especially complex errors that are difficult to describe in text alone this guide uses AI-generated images. All written values, diagnostics, and variety attributions have been manually reviewed against the cited sources above. While our editorial team works to ensure every image is accurate and helpful, AI-generated illustrations may occasionally misrepresent fine details. If you spot any discrepancy between an image and its written description, please contact us or leave a comment below we review all feedback and correct errors promptly. Numismatic knowledge is a community effort, and your input helps us build a more accurate resource for everyone.