fix: Disable materialized odfvs for historical retrieval by astronautas · Pull Request #5880 · feast-dev/feast · GitHub

What this PR does / why we need it:

See here. In essence, makes sure ODFV with write_to_online_store=True - meaning, cached - (on-demand feature views) get actually computed when querying offline store (get_historical_features) for training set generating, since as per docs (and generic expectation), offline stores do not store precomputed on demand feature view historical values (only online stores store their latest values).

Which issue(s) this PR fixes:

#5776

added some explanations for the context

@franciscojavierarceo

@ntkathole @franciscojavierarceo

FAILED sdk/python/tests/integration/registration/test_universal_registry.py::test_modify_feature_views_success[gcs_registry] - google.api_core.exceptions.TooManyRequests: 429 PUT https://storage.googleapis.com/upload/storage/v1/b/feast-registry-test-1768823153244/o?uploadType=resumable&upload_id=AJRbA5UkNFZsOvkuNKwLRRw4-oOTH9U9Rue973jdMFgJYYKN8LGRKVCmJ-cUy5ggGbPoW56hTKbEjwLItL1LPOaXkSaVZgZhZQbyu5gL4zsyKA: ***
  "error": ***
    "code": 429,
    "message": "The object feast-registry-test-1768823153244/registry.db exceeded the rate limit for object mutation operations (create, update, and delete). Please reduce your request rate. See https://cloud.google.com/storage/docs/gcs429.",
    "errors": [
      ***
        "message": "The object feast-registry-test-1768823153244/registry.db exceeded the rate limit for object mutation operations (create, update, and delete). Please reduce your request rate. See https://cloud.google.com/storage/docs/gcs429.",
        "domain": "usageLimits",
        "reason": "rateLimitExceeded"
      ***
    ]
  ***

seen this? Seems like a quota.

@franciscojavierarceo Seems to have passed now 😁

Pull request overview

This PR fixes an issue where materialized on-demand feature views (ODFVs) were incorrectly using precomputed values during historical retrieval operations. The fix ensures that ODFVs are always recomputed when querying the offline store for training set generation, aligning with the documented behavior that offline stores do not store precomputed ODFV values.

Changes:

Force ODFVs to recompute during historical retrieval by disabling write_to_online_store
Add pytest-xdist as a development dependency
Add a new Makefile target for running historical retrieval integration tests

Reviewed changes

Copilot reviewed 3 out of 3 changed files in this pull request and generated 3 comments.

File	Description
sdk/python/feast/feature_store.py	Disables write_to_online_store for all ODFVs before historical retrieval to ensure recomputation
pyproject.toml	Adds pytest-xdist development dependency for parallel test execution
Makefile	Adds new test target for running historical retrieval integration tests

💡 Add Copilot custom instructions for smarter, more guided reviews. Learn how to get started.

@franciscojavierarceo Random ray unit test failure, can we re-run? What's the way of self re-running the pipeline btw, seems akward asking you everytime haha.

@franciscojavierarceo Seems good now, also adjusted based on copilot suggestions ;)

i recently refactored some things to cleanup the code, looks like your changes remove them. can you fix that?

Signed-off-by: lukas.valatka <lukas.valatka@cast.ai>

@franciscojavierarceo Rebased, all good now!

…cal-retrieval

nice!

) Disable ODFVs for offline retrieval Signed-off-by: lukas.valatka <lukas.valatka@cast.ai> Signed-off-by: yassinnouh21 <yassinnouh21@gmail.com>

# [0.60.0](v0.59.0...v0.60.0) (2026-02-17) ### Bug Fixes * Added a flag to correctly download the go binaries ([0f77135](0f77135)) * Adds mapping of date Trino's type into string Feast's type ([531e839](531e839)) * **ci:** Use uv run for pytest in master_only benchmark step ([#5957](#5957)) ([5096010](5096010)) * Disable materialized odfvs for historical retrieval ([#5880](#5880)) ([739d28a](739d28a)) * Fix linting and formatting issues ([#5907](#5907)) ([42ca14a](42ca14a)) * Make timestamp field handling compatible with Athena V3 ([#5936](#5936)) ([e2bad34](e2bad34)) * Support pgvector under non-default schema ([#5970](#5970)) ([c636cd4](c636cd4)) * unit tests not running on main branch ([#5909](#5909)) ([62fe664](62fe664)) * Update java dep which blocking release ([#5903](#5903)) ([a5b8186](a5b8186)) * Update the dockerfile with golang 1.24.12. ([#5918](#5918)) ([be1b522](be1b522)) * Use context.Background() in client constructors ([#5897](#5897)) ([984f93a](984f93a)) ### Features * Add blog post for PyTorch ecosystem announcement ([#5906](#5906)) ([d2eb629](d2eb629)) * Add blog post on Feast dbt integration ([#5915](#5915)) ([b3c8138](b3c8138)) * Add DynamoDB in-place list update support for array-based features ([#5916](#5916)) ([aa5973f](aa5973f)) * Add HTTP connection pooling for remote online store client ([#5895](#5895)) ([e022bf8](e022bf8)) * Add integration tests for dbt import ([#5899](#5899)) ([a444692](a444692)) * Add lazy initialization and feature service caching ([#5924](#5924)) ([b37b7d0](b37b7d0)) * Add multiple entity support to dbt integration ([#5901](#5901)) ([05a4fb5](05a4fb5)), closes [#5872](#5872) * Add PostgreSQL online store support for Go feature server ([#5963](#5963)) ([b8c6f3d](b8c6f3d)) * Add publish docker image of Go feature server. ([#5923](#5923)) ([759d8c6](759d8c6)) * Add Set as feature type ([#5888](#5888)) ([52458fc](52458fc)) * Added online server worker config support in operator ([#5926](#5926)) ([193c72a](193c72a)) * Added support for OpenLineage integration ([#5884](#5884)) ([df70d8d](df70d8d)) * Adjust ray offline store to support abfs(s) ADLS Azure Storage ([#5911](#5911)) ([d6c0b2d](d6c0b2d)) * Batch_engine config injection in feature_store.yaml through operator ([#5938](#5938)) ([455d56c](455d56c)) * Consolidate Python packaging - remove setup.py/setup.cfg, standardize on pyproject.toml and uv ([16696b8](16696b8)) * **go:** Add MySQL registry store support for Go feature server ([#5933](#5933)) ([19f9bb8](19f9bb8)) * Improve local dev experience with file-aware hooks and auto parallelization ([#5956](#5956)) ([839b79e](839b79e)) * Modernize precommit hooks and optimize test performance ([#5929](#5929)) ([ea7d4fa](ea7d4fa)) * Optimize container infrastructure for production ([#5881](#5881)) ([5ebdac8](5ebdac8)) * Optimize DynamoDB online store for improved latency ([#5889](#5889)) ([fcc8274](fcc8274))

# [0.60.0](feast-dev/feast@v0.59.0...v0.60.0) (2026-02-17) ### Bug Fixes * Added a flag to correctly download the go binaries ([0f77135](feast-dev@0f77135)) * Adds mapping of date Trino's type into string Feast's type ([531e839](feast-dev@531e839)) * **ci:** Use uv run for pytest in master_only benchmark step ([feast-dev#5957](feast-dev#5957)) ([5096010](feast-dev@5096010)) * Disable materialized odfvs for historical retrieval ([feast-dev#5880](feast-dev#5880)) ([739d28a](feast-dev@739d28a)) * Fix linting and formatting issues ([feast-dev#5907](feast-dev#5907)) ([42ca14a](feast-dev@42ca14a)) * Make timestamp field handling compatible with Athena V3 ([feast-dev#5936](feast-dev#5936)) ([e2bad34](feast-dev@e2bad34)) * Support pgvector under non-default schema ([feast-dev#5970](feast-dev#5970)) ([c636cd4](feast-dev@c636cd4)) * unit tests not running on main branch ([feast-dev#5909](feast-dev#5909)) ([62fe664](feast-dev@62fe664)) * Update java dep which blocking release ([feast-dev#5903](feast-dev#5903)) ([a5b8186](feast-dev@a5b8186)) * Update the dockerfile with golang 1.24.12. ([feast-dev#5918](feast-dev#5918)) ([be1b522](feast-dev@be1b522)) * Use context.Background() in client constructors ([feast-dev#5897](feast-dev#5897)) ([984f93a](feast-dev@984f93a)) ### Features * Add blog post for PyTorch ecosystem announcement ([feast-dev#5906](feast-dev#5906)) ([d2eb629](feast-dev@d2eb629)) * Add blog post on Feast dbt integration ([feast-dev#5915](feast-dev#5915)) ([b3c8138](feast-dev@b3c8138)) * Add DynamoDB in-place list update support for array-based features ([feast-dev#5916](feast-dev#5916)) ([aa5973f](feast-dev@aa5973f)) * Add HTTP connection pooling for remote online store client ([feast-dev#5895](feast-dev#5895)) ([e022bf8](feast-dev@e022bf8)) * Add integration tests for dbt import ([feast-dev#5899](feast-dev#5899)) ([a444692](feast-dev@a444692)) * Add lazy initialization and feature service caching ([feast-dev#5924](feast-dev#5924)) ([b37b7d0](feast-dev@b37b7d0)) * Add multiple entity support to dbt integration ([feast-dev#5901](feast-dev#5901)) ([05a4fb5](feast-dev@05a4fb5)), closes [feast-dev#5872](feast-dev#5872) * Add PostgreSQL online store support for Go feature server ([feast-dev#5963](feast-dev#5963)) ([b8c6f3d](feast-dev@b8c6f3d)) * Add publish docker image of Go feature server. ([feast-dev#5923](feast-dev#5923)) ([759d8c6](feast-dev@759d8c6)) * Add Set as feature type ([feast-dev#5888](feast-dev#5888)) ([52458fc](feast-dev@52458fc)) * Added online server worker config support in operator ([feast-dev#5926](feast-dev#5926)) ([193c72a](feast-dev@193c72a)) * Added support for OpenLineage integration ([feast-dev#5884](feast-dev#5884)) ([df70d8d](feast-dev@df70d8d)) * Adjust ray offline store to support abfs(s) ADLS Azure Storage ([feast-dev#5911](feast-dev#5911)) ([d6c0b2d](feast-dev@d6c0b2d)) * Batch_engine config injection in feature_store.yaml through operator ([feast-dev#5938](feast-dev#5938)) ([455d56c](feast-dev@455d56c)) * Consolidate Python packaging - remove setup.py/setup.cfg, standardize on pyproject.toml and uv ([16696b8](feast-dev@16696b8)) * **go:** Add MySQL registry store support for Go feature server ([feast-dev#5933](feast-dev#5933)) ([19f9bb8](feast-dev@19f9bb8)) * Improve local dev experience with file-aware hooks and auto parallelization ([feast-dev#5956](feast-dev#5956)) ([839b79e](feast-dev@839b79e)) * Modernize precommit hooks and optimize test performance ([feast-dev#5929](feast-dev#5929)) ([ea7d4fa](feast-dev@ea7d4fa)) * Optimize container infrastructure for production ([feast-dev#5881](feast-dev#5881)) ([5ebdac8](feast-dev@5ebdac8)) * Optimize DynamoDB online store for improved latency ([feast-dev#5889](feast-dev#5889)) ([fcc8274](feast-dev@fcc8274)) Signed-off-by: soojin <soojin@dable.io>

) Disable ODFVs for offline retrieval Signed-off-by: lukas.valatka <lukas.valatka@cast.ai>

# [0.60.0](feast-dev/feast@v0.59.0...v0.60.0) (2026-02-17) ### Bug Fixes * Added a flag to correctly download the go binaries ([0f77135](feast-dev@0f77135)) * Adds mapping of date Trino's type into string Feast's type ([531e839](feast-dev@531e839)) * **ci:** Use uv run for pytest in master_only benchmark step ([feast-dev#5957](feast-dev#5957)) ([5096010](feast-dev@5096010)) * Disable materialized odfvs for historical retrieval ([feast-dev#5880](feast-dev#5880)) ([739d28a](feast-dev@739d28a)) * Fix linting and formatting issues ([feast-dev#5907](feast-dev#5907)) ([42ca14a](feast-dev@42ca14a)) * Make timestamp field handling compatible with Athena V3 ([feast-dev#5936](feast-dev#5936)) ([e2bad34](feast-dev@e2bad34)) * Support pgvector under non-default schema ([feast-dev#5970](feast-dev#5970)) ([c636cd4](feast-dev@c636cd4)) * unit tests not running on main branch ([feast-dev#5909](feast-dev#5909)) ([62fe664](feast-dev@62fe664)) * Update java dep which blocking release ([feast-dev#5903](feast-dev#5903)) ([a5b8186](feast-dev@a5b8186)) * Update the dockerfile with golang 1.24.12. ([feast-dev#5918](feast-dev#5918)) ([be1b522](feast-dev@be1b522)) * Use context.Background() in client constructors ([feast-dev#5897](feast-dev#5897)) ([984f93a](feast-dev@984f93a)) ### Features * Add blog post for PyTorch ecosystem announcement ([feast-dev#5906](feast-dev#5906)) ([d2eb629](feast-dev@d2eb629)) * Add blog post on Feast dbt integration ([feast-dev#5915](feast-dev#5915)) ([b3c8138](feast-dev@b3c8138)) * Add DynamoDB in-place list update support for array-based features ([feast-dev#5916](feast-dev#5916)) ([aa5973f](feast-dev@aa5973f)) * Add HTTP connection pooling for remote online store client ([feast-dev#5895](feast-dev#5895)) ([e022bf8](feast-dev@e022bf8)) * Add integration tests for dbt import ([feast-dev#5899](feast-dev#5899)) ([a444692](feast-dev@a444692)) * Add lazy initialization and feature service caching ([feast-dev#5924](feast-dev#5924)) ([b37b7d0](feast-dev@b37b7d0)) * Add multiple entity support to dbt integration ([feast-dev#5901](feast-dev#5901)) ([05a4fb5](feast-dev@05a4fb5)), closes [feast-dev#5872](feast-dev#5872) * Add PostgreSQL online store support for Go feature server ([feast-dev#5963](feast-dev#5963)) ([b8c6f3d](feast-dev@b8c6f3d)) * Add publish docker image of Go feature server. ([feast-dev#5923](feast-dev#5923)) ([759d8c6](feast-dev@759d8c6)) * Add Set as feature type ([feast-dev#5888](feast-dev#5888)) ([52458fc](feast-dev@52458fc)) * Added online server worker config support in operator ([feast-dev#5926](feast-dev#5926)) ([193c72a](feast-dev@193c72a)) * Added support for OpenLineage integration ([feast-dev#5884](feast-dev#5884)) ([df70d8d](feast-dev@df70d8d)) * Adjust ray offline store to support abfs(s) ADLS Azure Storage ([feast-dev#5911](feast-dev#5911)) ([d6c0b2d](feast-dev@d6c0b2d)) * Batch_engine config injection in feature_store.yaml through operator ([feast-dev#5938](feast-dev#5938)) ([455d56c](feast-dev@455d56c)) * Consolidate Python packaging - remove setup.py/setup.cfg, standardize on pyproject.toml and uv ([16696b8](feast-dev@16696b8)) * **go:** Add MySQL registry store support for Go feature server ([feast-dev#5933](feast-dev#5933)) ([19f9bb8](feast-dev@19f9bb8)) * Improve local dev experience with file-aware hooks and auto parallelization ([feast-dev#5956](feast-dev#5956)) ([839b79e](feast-dev@839b79e)) * Modernize precommit hooks and optimize test performance ([feast-dev#5929](feast-dev#5929)) ([ea7d4fa](feast-dev@ea7d4fa)) * Optimize container infrastructure for production ([feast-dev#5881](feast-dev#5881)) ([5ebdac8](feast-dev@5ebdac8)) * Optimize DynamoDB online store for improved latency ([feast-dev#5889](feast-dev#5889)) ([fcc8274](feast-dev@fcc8274)) Signed-off-by: Shizoqua <hr.lanreshittu@gmail.com>

astronautas requested a review from a team as a code owner January 19, 2026 07:08

astronautas force-pushed the fix/disable-materialized-odfvs-for-historical-retrieval branch from 78ff90f to c2e42d0 Compare January 19, 2026 07:09

astronautas changed the title Fix/disable materialized odfvs for historical retrieval fix: disable materialized odfvs for historical retrieval Jan 19, 2026

astronautas changed the title fix: disable materialized odfvs for historical retrieval Fix: disable materialized odfvs for historical retrieval Jan 19, 2026

astronautas changed the title Fix: disable materialized odfvs for historical retrieval fix: Disable materialized odfvs for historical retrieval Jan 19, 2026

astronautas commented Jan 19, 2026

View reviewed changes

Comment thread pyproject.toml

astronautas commented Jan 19, 2026

View reviewed changes

Comment thread Makefile

astronautas commented Jan 19, 2026

View reviewed changes

Comment thread sdk/python/feast/feature_store.py

franciscojavierarceo approved these changes Jan 19, 2026

View reviewed changes

franciscojavierarceo added the ok-to-test label Jan 19, 2026

franciscojavierarceo reviewed Jan 20, 2026

View reviewed changes

Comment thread sdk/python/feast/feature_store.py

franciscojavierarceo requested a review from Copilot January 20, 2026 13:32

Copilot AI reviewed Jan 20, 2026

View reviewed changes

Comment thread sdk/python/feast/feature_store.py

Comment thread sdk/python/feast/feature_store.py

Comment thread Makefile

astronautas force-pushed the fix/disable-materialized-odfvs-for-historical-retrieval branch from 0ff5dc2 to dafd8d2 Compare January 21, 2026 07:50

franciscojavierarceo reviewed Jan 22, 2026

View reviewed changes

Comment thread sdk/python/feast/on_demand_feature_view.py

franciscojavierarceo requested changes Jan 22, 2026

View reviewed changes

Disable ODFVs for offline retrieval

44e8076

Signed-off-by: lukas.valatka <lukas.valatka@cast.ai>

astronautas force-pushed the fix/disable-materialized-odfvs-for-historical-retrieval branch from dafd8d2 to 44e8076 Compare January 22, 2026 15:02

Merge branch 'master' into fix/disable-materialized-odfvs-for-histori…

d1a3564

…cal-retrieval

franciscojavierarceo reviewed Jan 26, 2026

View reviewed changes

franciscojavierarceo approved these changes Jan 26, 2026

View reviewed changes

franciscojavierarceo merged commit 739d28a into feast-dev:master Jan 26, 2026
17 checks passed

jyejare pushed a commit to opendatahub-io/feast that referenced this pull request Mar 9, 2026

fix: Disable materialized odfvs for historical retrieval (feast-dev#5880

f8b8e64

) Disable ODFVs for offline retrieval Signed-off-by: lukas.valatka <lukas.valatka@cast.ai>

               			not test_snowflake" \
                	 sdk/python/tests
+              test-python-historical-retrieval:

fix: Disable materialized odfvs for historical retrieval by astronautas · Pull Request #5880 · feast-dev/feast · GitHub

Uh oh!

fix: Disable materialized odfvs for historical retrieval - #5880

Conversation

astronautas commented Jan 19, 2026 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

What this PR does / why we need it:

Which issue(s) this PR fixes:

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

astronautas commented Jan 19, 2026

Uh oh!

astronautas commented Jan 19, 2026

Uh oh!

astronautas commented Jan 19, 2026

Uh oh!

astronautas commented Jan 19, 2026

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Copilot AI left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Pull request overview

Reviewed changes

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

astronautas commented Jan 21, 2026

Uh oh!

astronautas commented Jan 22, 2026

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

franciscojavierarceo left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

astronautas commented Jan 22, 2026

Uh oh!

franciscojavierarceo Jan 26, 2026

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

3 participants

astronautas commented Jan 19, 2026 •
edited
Loading