Allow setting per-repo SSH key · Issue #234 · gitpython-developers/GitPython · GitHub

I've locally patched this by temporarily setting the GIT_SSH environment variable to a script that would include a deployment SSH key in the SSH command. I think this would be awesome to have built-in. I find this much more convenient and flexible than having to parse and update the ~/.ssh/config.

Would there be interest in a pull request for this feature?

Of course, I would be looking forward to receiving one.
I will assign this ticket to the 'far in the future' release until I receive a PR or get around to implementing this myself.
Version 0.3.6 could be released this week, and your PR could be part of it if it makes it here in time.
Thank you

Glad to hear that. I'm looking into it! :)

Right now, I'm trying to figure out what would be the best syntax to support it. Should it be a keyword argument to fetch/pull/clone/push?

remote.pull(sshkey=GIT_SSH_KEY)

or

Repo.clone_from(git_url, repo_dir, sshkey=GIT_SSH_KEY)

Or a property of Remote that gets passed in upon instantiation? If you need it for either of fetch/pull/clone/push, then you will need it for all other commands too, so the latter seems more appropriate. But remote objects may not have been initialized by the user, so what do we do if it wasn't?

In my own class, I've made it a context manager that temporarily injects GIT_SSH into the environment, something like:

with repo.git.environment(sshkey=GIT_SSH_KEY):
    remote.pull()

but this may get repetitive really fast...

Being much more familiar with the codebase than I am, what's your favorite/opinion/recommendation? I'm also open to other proposals and implementation suggestions!

From what I see, you have pinpointed the options precisely already !

If your envisioned implementation indeed sets environment variables that are to be inherited by called git processes, it might be most comfortable to set it up where it happens, in the Git type.

In that case, the API could look like this:

r = git.Repo('repo_dir')
previous_env = r.git.set_environment(dict(GIT_SSH_KEY="I really don't know what to pass here ;)"))
# Now all upcoming git calls will have the GIT_SSH_KEY environment variable set, along with all the other default ones.
# Returning the previous version of the dict (which may be empty) helps to change environments on the fly, for example with a custom context manager.

As you can see, my suggestion is very generic, but should be just what you need to get GIT_SSH_KEY to work.

Additionally, it would be great if you could add a small tutorial to the respective sphinx rst file, along with a test for the example code in test_docs.py .

I hope that makes sense, please let me know if there are any other questions or concerns, I will be happy to help.

How it works is: The GIT_SSH environment variable points to an executable (e.g. a python script) that will be used instead of ssh. This script then simply calls ssh, passing the SSH key and all passed options. That is, given environment variables like

GIT_SSH_KEY='/home/user/gitrepo/deployment_key'
GIT_SSH='/usr/local/lib/python2.7/dist-packages/git/scripts/ssh_with_key.py'

the mentioned $GIT_SSH script (ssh_with_key.py) would pretty much be:

ssh_options = ['-i', os.environ['GIT_SSH_KEY']]
return subprocess.call(['ssh'] + ssh_options + sys.argv[1:])

git uses the complete value of GIT_SSH as the program name, so you can't just dynamically set it to ssh -i $GIT_SSH_KEY. Hence the need for an extra script to help out.

What I like about a context manager is that it wouldn't affect other remotes if you are operating on more than one. But maybe we could just have both options, where the context manager uses the API that you're suggesting. :-)

Thanks for the heads-up !
In that case, I definitely put my votes on the general environment API I previously proposed, along with the said configuration manager. The latter would just swap environments accordingly.

I am looking forward to your PR ! No pressure, but I intend to make a new release today or tomorrow, and unless you don't have some code already, I might just implement this one for you if you don't mind. It seems like a thing of 45 minutes to me.

I'm happy to let you implement it :-) You surely have a better feeling of where everything should go! Here's what I thought how set_environment could work:

def set_environment(self, **kwargs):
    old_env = {}
    for key, value in kwargs.iteritems():
        # set value if it is None
        if value is not None:
            if key in os.environ:
                old_env[key] = os.environ[key]
            else:
                old_env[key] = None
            os.environ[key] = value
        # remove key from environment if its value is None
        elif key in os.environ:
            old_env[key] = os.environ[key]
            del os.environ[key]
    return old_env

With that function, the context manager would be as easy as doing:

@contextlib.contextmanager
def patch_environment(self, **kwargs):
    old_env = self.set_environment(**kwargs)
    yield
    self.set_environment(old_env)

For testing it, you could generate a new SSH key and set it as the deployment key for this repository. Or that's the path I would have taken. :-)

Hmm, why don't we work on this so you can put this code up into a branch which I can use as a basis. That way you can get your name into the project and get some more reward for your time :) !

The main issue I take here is that the os.environ is off the charts for the "we don't change globals" reason. The additional environment variables could be stored in a member variable though, which gets merged into the process environment about here, overwriting existing values if necessary.

If you can manage to post your branch to be used say, until tomorrow, I will definitely merge it in. That's the timeframe I expect myself to be done with all other tickets.

Good luck !

Sounds good too, I pretty much have all the pieces together. :-) Then you can concentrate on other tickets!

You can watch the archived live-stream on youtube

Removed Git.sshkey() as it couldn't be distributed properly.

Turns out, starting with git 2.3, this is pretty much built-in. Using the new GIT_SSH_COMMAND, you can specify the ssh -i ... command now directly, rather than relying on an external script. :-) And even better, with the environment context manager, it's fully supported too! :-)

I am glad to hear that ! In a way it seems it was good that setuptools refused to make that extra script executable - it would have been unnecessary special-case baggage after all.
Happy End ... (? ;) )

Yeah it was quite special-case, no hard feelings. :-)

@teeberg Maybe you can chime in on this question on stackoverflow. He keeps posting in the comments of my answer though - maybe it's worth a new question so you can earn some points as well :).

@teeberg Here is the new question - maybe you know what's happening there.

I'll look into it :-) Thanks for letting me know!

Allow setting per-repo SSH key · Issue #234 · gitpython-developers/GitPython · GitHub

Repository navigation

Allow setting per-repo SSH key #234

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Allow setting per-repo SSH key · Issue #234 · gitpython-developers/GitPython · GitHub

Repository navigation

Allow setting per-repo SSH key #234

Description

Activity

Byron commented on Jan 19, 2015

teeberg commented on Jan 20, 2015

Byron commented on Jan 20, 2015

teeberg commented on Jan 21, 2015

Byron commented on Jan 21, 2015

teeberg commented on Jan 21, 2015

Byron commented on Jan 21, 2015

teeberg commented on Jan 21, 2015

Byron commented on Jan 22, 2015

teeberg commented on Feb 9, 2015

Byron commented on Feb 9, 2015

teeberg commented on Feb 9, 2015

Byron commented on Mar 2, 2015

Byron commented on Mar 2, 2015

teeberg commented on Mar 2, 2015

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions